Miscellaneous >> Tasawwuf

Question ID: 350Country: ZA

Title: Is gathering of communal loud thikr in the Masaajid permissible?

Question: Is gathering of communal loud thikr in the Masaajid permissible?

Answer ID: 350Posted on: Sep 1, 2020

Bismillah hir-Rahman nir-Rahim !

(Fatwa: 16=162/L)

If there is none offering salah, and people get involved in loud Zikr individually then it is allowed even it seemingly creates a scene of collective Zikr:

وفي حاشیة الحموي للشعراني: قد اجمع العلماء سلفاً و خلفاً علی استحباب ذکر الجماعة في المساجد وغیرھا الا ان یشوش جھرھم علی نائم او مصل او قارئ (شامي: 2/434، ط زکریا، دیوبند)

Allah (Subhana Wa Ta'ala) knows Best

Darul Ifta,

Darul Uloom Deoband, India

Related Questions

Q. What is the best way for a woman to get benfit from one's shaykh. Can she talk to him and if so what is the best way according to sunnah and shariah. 2062 views
Q. I will be grateful if you can provide me the names of all Sheikh's of Hazrat Haji Imdad ULLAH Muhajir Makki(RA)(means Naqashbandi Sheikh, Chisti Sheikh, Suhrwardi Sheikh and Qadri Sheikh). May Allah Bless all Ummah. 6262 views
Q. Assalam-o-Alaikum. Can you explain precisely in detail the concept of "wahdat-al-wajood"? I went to other deobandi maslak websites, but they always give a simple definition and then say there are other details we can not discuss. Kindly I need full details please. 5547 views
Q. Tell any best wazifa to purify heart and nafs and spiritual progress. 4898 views
Q. Ibn Arabi said, "العبد رب و الرب عبد" or "al-`abd-u rabb-un wa-r-rabb-u `abd-un" (the slave is the lord and the lord is the slave)." Sufis claim that such statements were always considered to be the most elevated exposition of mystical thought in Islam, and therefore unsuitable for the untrained mind. Ibn Arabi has also said, "الرب رب في التنزل والعبد عبد في الترقى" or "ar-rabb-u rabb-un f? t-tanazzul-i wa-l-`abd-u `abd-un f? t-taraqq?" (The lord is a lord in his descent [to his creations] and a slave is a slave in rising). in Fusoos Al-Hikam" and "Al-Ahkaam. Is such aqeedah right?IF yes what does it mean, please explain it clearly. 5450 views
Q. My one friend is a mureed of some peer.and that peer himself is not keeping beard and peer saheb also said to my friend that "tumhari nani ko haj naseeb nahin hoga" so i want to know whether such person can be a real peer & whether he can say such statements related to future? Kindly guide us. 2740 views
Q. I would be extremely appreciative if you could take the time to inform me of the Deobandi stance on the Hadra Zikr of Sufis; moreover of it's legal status and the reasoning behind this? 4497 views
Q. Looking for Sheikh for bait in Lahore Pakistan 3327 views
Q. Knowledge 3693 views
Q. going in jamaat 2999 views
Q. In my childhood one of the shaykhs of chishtiya silsila arrived in our city.people were getting bait with him but i dint knew whats happening people were holding the towel and were repeating some kalimat.i after being told did the same.is this bait counted or if i wish i can get bait to the shaykh whom heart permises. 3703 views
Q. Is gathering of communal loud thikr in the Masaajid permissible? 2467 views
Q. 1)Are we allowed to pray khatme khwajgan? 2)What is the significance and reward? 3)Can it be prayed in majlis or gathering? 4)If it is allowed can you please send details of the supplication - what is prayed how many times? JZK 14007 views
Q. Do we get any benefits by doing spiritual communion (Muraqiba) at the graves of saints? 3617 views
Q. I attend regularly the majalis and bayans of a Shaikh who is majaz of Hakeem Akhtar Sahib Damat Barkhatuh and Alhamdulillah gaining a lot of benefits in self reformation 2349 views

Total Questions: 9181

Faiths & Beliefs

Miscellaneous

Prayers & Duties

Social Matters

Transactions & Dealings

Title: Is gathering of communal loud thikr in the Masaajid permissible?

Question: Is gathering of communal loud thikr in the Masaajid permissible?

Related Questions