Faiths & Beliefs >> Islamic Beliefs

Question ID: 36952Country: Pakistan

Title: Please tell me that when a person who is away from Madinah says 'Ya Rasul Allah', did he commit a shirk? I am very much confused about this issue

Question: . I heard some people saying that it is alright to say so, while some say that it comes under shirk.

Answer ID: 36952Posted on: Sep 1, 2020

Bismillah hir-Rahman nir-Rahim !

(Fatwa: 436/287/D=1433) If someone says "Ya Rasul Allah" with the belief that the holy Prophet Muhammad (صلى الله عليه وسلم) is omnipresent and omniscient and he listens to our calls and requests and fulfils our needs, so this is unlawful and shirk. But instead of the said belief, if someone pronounced "Ya Rasul Allah" sometime out of utmost love then it is allowable but it is better to avoid this word since it involves a doubt of shirk.

Allah (Subhana Wa Ta'ala) knows Best

Darul Ifta,

Darul Uloom Deoband, India

Related Questions

Q. If the shia people , uses the word MOLA , before the name of hazrat Ali (R.A.T.A) i.e MOLA ALI , can we say that they are saying hazrat ALi is God (nauzubillah) and we can decide that they are kafir. and what about the people who ask for help from others as well as from Allah e.g ya rusool Allah Imadad, ya Ali madad and alike? are they committing shirk? and are they still muslims? 15616 views
Q. Naming the New Born and Aqiqah Procedure 2122 views
Q. Misunderstanding about virtues of Some Sura 3992 views
Q. Sometimes people ask me whether am i wahabi or sunni? What to answer them? 3013 views
Q. It has been said that by wearig certain stones it gives good luck to a person, is it permissible to wear a silver ring with a specific stone on it with the intention that because of the specific stone on the ring Allah will give good luck? 2-0r is it Shirk? please provide refrence. 3495 views
Q. 1. What is the ruling of Kufer in Hanafi if a muslim miss obligatory prayer: a. Non-Deliberately b. Deliberayely 2. I heard that if a muslim miss three juma prayer than he is out of islam. 4203 views
Q. I have heard from people that mehdi (alais salam) have come into this world a few years ago and he is alive now .is it true. wat are signs of mehdi (alais salam) coming into this world? 1925 views
Q. Kya agar kisi wali ya auliyaki mazar pe jakar yeh kahena ki ya shaikh, ya gauth aap meri duva allah ki bargah me pahocha dijiye, aap mere liye duva kare, allah aapki duva bahoot jald kabool karte hai, kya aisa aqida rakhna durast hai ya nahi. Aur dusra kya ek muslman ko barelvi bhi nahi hai aur deobandi bhi nahi to kya woh muslman hoga, matlabt woh ahle sunnatval jamat par kayam rahega ya nahi. 2782 views
Q. In West Bengal there is worshiped Swaraswati Puja in every school . We, the Muslim have to participate or to co-operate in many ways . Students are forced to donate money for worshipping the idols. How can we remove ourselves from this Shirk? 2696 views
Q. When barelwi perform salam to rasool Allah they stand up, what i have to do, to sitdown or i have to stand up also. 5203 views
Q. Is it allow to seek sadak of Rasul-allah (SAW) and other auliya in dua? Generally in dua we use word like "Allah give me so and so as sadaka of so and so (Rasul or auliya)". Is it allow? 2187 views
Q. Assalam o alaykum, Salam o alaykum, What is the ruling on those who believe that Holy Prophet knew the Quran even before his birth (Qabal wiladat hi arif-i-Quran thay). But He Nabi didn't propagate it until it was revelaved to him through Jibrail? JazakAllah. 1758 views
Q. In my family every one is barelvi sunni except my mother,sister & my wife.my father is pakka barelvi , I am offering salah in deobandi & barelvi masjid .but my father is asking me to offer salah only barelvi masjid, he is telling me that u became wahabi,creating tension in my family my mother is taking my side,he telling that i will give talaq if u take your son side. .and he is asking me to leave deobandi sasjid or himself,is i am doing nafarmani of him.i like jamat.is it right to offer salah behind barelvi imam because they are calling nabi pak as ya rasullah in their darud and before azan is not they doing shirk ? 6232 views
Q. What is our belief about Allah? Like Allah has mentioned in the Quran the following things about himself. (1) Hands and (2) Face etc. Please let us know. 5122 views
Q. Is it haram to wear a silver chain for men. Can we perform Salah/Namaz wearing silver chain 11298 views

Total Questions: 9181

Faiths & Beliefs

Miscellaneous

Prayers & Duties

Social Matters

Transactions & Dealings

Title: Please tell me that when a person who is away from Madinah says 'Ya Rasul Allah', did he commit a shirk? I am very much confused about this issue

Question: . I heard some people saying that it is alright to say so, while some say that it comes under shirk.

Related Questions